Place your order for pick-up! You will have the option of where to pick up your pies:

  1. at the Right Slice Bakery in Lihue (Puhi):  1543 Haleukana Street, 11-6 M-Sat, closed Sundays
  2. at the Right Slice Bakery in Kalaheo: 2-2459 Kaumualii Hwy, 11-6 M-Sat, 7-2 Sundays (Coming Soon!)
  3. at Kukui’ula Culinary Market, Wednesday 4-6
  4. at Waipa Farmer’s Market, Tuesday 1:30-3, (northshore)
Blueberry Ginger
Blueberry Ginger

A Delightful combination of organic blueberries and fresh locally grown ginger. A classic with a local twist.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Blueberry Pina Colada
Blueberry Pina Colada

A unique blend of organic blueberries, fresh Hawaii pineapple and coconut milk, topped with a sweet and crunchy coconut crumb topping.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Blueberry, Basil & Goat Cheese
Blueberry, Basil & Goat Cheese

A sweet and savory mix made perfect with organic blueberries and fresh locally grown basil. Add in a spattering of tangy goat cheese for a truly unique dessert!

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Packaging :
Classic Apple
Classic Apple

A traditional favorite.Crisp granny smith apples from Washington combined with just the right amount of cinnamon and sugar.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Island Lemon
Island Lemon

Locally grown Meyer Lemons, squeezed at their peak of ripeness combined with just the right amount of sugar for a sweet and tart dessert. The unique double crust of this pie offers a great variation on lemon pie.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Island Lime
Island Lime

One of the owner's personal favorites. Local Tahitian or Rangpur Limes, depending on your order, combined with just the right amount of sugar for a sweet and tart dessert. The unique double crust of this pie offers a great variation on lime pie. Note: this is NOT a Key Lime Pie. A great description is that this is more similar to a Lemon Meringue Pie without the Meringue.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Lilikoi
Lilikoi

A smooth, tangy lilikoi curd topped with a sugar crust... what a unique pie. Light and not too heavy for dessert.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Mango Lilikoi
Mango Lilikoi

Our #1 seller. Plump juicy mangoes combined with just the right amount of passionfruit and topped with a sugar crust. A perfect tropical ending to any meal.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Meringue
Meringue

Choose one of our delicious curds: lemon, lime, guava or lilikoi - and add a meringue. All from scratch!

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Please Note: Meringue Pies may ONLY be picked up at our Puhi Retail Location.

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Flavor :
Packaging :
Mountain Apple
Mountain Apple

A fresh light local favorite... seasonal only.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Alternate Choice:
Peach
Peach

(Seasonal) Perfectly ripened peaches combined with a touch of cinnamon for a delicate flavor combination. This pie is often also available with white peaches which gives a more subtle smooth flavor to the pie.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Alternate Choice:
Peach Melba
Peach Melba

Add fresh raspberries to your delicious peach pie for a fun twist.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Alternate Choice:
Pina Colada
Pina Colada

A tropical delight. Fresh island pineapples chunked up and mixed with shredded coconut to produce this light dessert. Note... this pie does contain eggs.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Tropical Banana
Tropical Banana

One of our signature flavors. Beautifully ripened, locally grown, apple bananas combine with a touch of pineapple to create this wonderful hearty pie. We use 5 pounds of bananas in EACH pie.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :
Alternate Choice:
Tropical Trio
Tropical Trio

Mango, pineapple and candied ginger in a flaky double crust pie.

Available in 2 sizes: 8" baby pie for $19 or large deep-dish pie for $38 (plus a $10 refundable pie plate deposit).

Price: $19.00
Size :
Dietary Options :
Packaging :

the Right Slice Shopping Cart

Your cart is empty
Visit The Shop
Share