Showing all 16 results

Sort by:
  • 0 out of 5
    Caramel Apple Pie (Pickup)
    $23.04
    0 out of 5

    Just like a caramel apple from the fair! Tart, crunchy granny smith apples, topped with a crumb topping and generously drizzled with caramel sauce. Also available Gluten-Free (no crumbs… top crust only.)

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Creamy Carrot Custard Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    A fun twist on traditional pumpkin pie. Organic carrots, locally grown when we can get them, cooked tender and combined with rich custard ingredients. Baked to a creamy perfection. Available all year long!

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Chocolate Coconut Macaroon Pie (Pickup)
    $23.04
    0 out of 5

    Our most decadent offering. A layer of toasted coconut topped with chocolate ganache and a layer of coconut custard creates this delicious pie. This pie does contain eggs.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Lilikoi Cheesecake (Pickup)
    $23.04
    0 out of 5

    A delightful blend of tangy lilikoi with creamy cheesecake make this a top five pie at The Right Slice. Layered on a graham cracker crust, this pie is lighter than its New York Style mainland cousin.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Macadamia Nut Pie (Pickup)
    $23.04
    0 out of 5

    Another island favorite. We use island macadamia nuts, roasted to a perfect golden brown. Combine this with eggs, sugar and fresh spices for a delicious tropical ending to any meal. Add in chocolate chips or our local Koloa Rum for $3 extra. A Gluten-Free option is also available (but not available with the Rum Mix-In).

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Paradise Pie (Pickup)
    $23.04
    0 out of 5

    Macadamia Nut Pie with a twist. We add fresh local island pineapple and toasted coconut to our already decadent macadamia nut pie.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    A delicate blend of our traditional vanilla cheesecake and grandma’s pumpkin pie in a graham cracker crust.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Pecan Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    A seasonal classic… but if you haven’t tried it yet, we highly recommend our tropical spin with a Macadamia Nut pie instead. Add in chocolate chips or our local Koloa Rum for $3 extra. A Gluten-Free option is also available (but not available with the Rum Mix-In).

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Pumpkin Pake (Pickup)
    $23.04
    0 out of 5

    A moist pumpkin filling loaded with all your favorite autumn spices, which is a lovely cross between a cake and a pumpkin pie. Baked to perfection in our hand rolled butter crust. Topped with a light and airy cream cheese frosting. Seasonal, only available November through January.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Pumpkin Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    A holiday favorite… this is the owner’s grandma’s recipe. You don’t want to miss this one… mixed with just the right autumn spices for a nice holiday flavor.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Belgian Chocolate Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    A chocolate lovers delight! A twist between a dark mousse and a pudding. 55% dark chocolate combined with milk and eggs to create this delicious homemade pastry cream. Fabulous topped with our homemade whipped cream. Add your favorite fixin for $3 extra or 2 fixins for $5. Please note that in the tropical Hawaiian heat this pie must be refrigerated ASAP.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Island Lemon Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    Locally grown Meyer Lemons, squeezed at their peak of ripeness combined with just the right amount of sugar for a sweet and tart dessert. The unique double crust of this pie offers a great variation on lemon pie.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Island Lime Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    One of the owner’s personal favorites. Local Tahitian or Rangpur Limes, depending on the season of your order, combined with just the right amount of sugar for a sweet and tart dessert. The unique double crust of this pie offers a great variation on lime pie. Note: this is NOT a Key Lime Pie. A great description is that this is more similar to a Lemon Meringue Pie without the Meringue.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Lilikoi Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    A smooth, tangy lilikoi curd topped with a sugar crust… what a unique pie. Light and not too heavy for dessert.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Blueberry Pina Colada Pie (Pickup)
    $19.20
    0 out of 5

    A unique blend of organic blueberries, fresh Hawaii pineapple and coconut milk, topped with a sweet and crunchy coconut crumb topping.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Tropical Trio Pie (Pickup)
    $23.04
    0 out of 5

    Mango, pineapple and candied ginger in a flaky double crust pie.

    Available as a baby pie (5-6 servings), a large pie (8-10 servings) or a deep dish pie (8-12 servings). Receive a $10 bakery credit when you return your glass deep-dish pan. See more info in the Description below.