This is where you can browse products in this store.
We are currently offering only 2 pie sizes for online orders:
Baby (serves 5-6) and Medium (serves 8-10)

Showing 1–21 of 67 results

Sort by:
  • 0 out of 5
    Pie Shipping Tests
    $50.00
    0 out of 5

    Test Shipment Pie Deposit: $50 plus taxes and fees

    If you have been chosen to help us with our pie shipping tests, please order this item in your shopping cart today.  Your credit card will be charged the full amount. Once we receive your pie homework, within 3 business days of your pie’s delivery, this fee will be refunded to you. Please know the actual refund can take 3-5 business days from the credit card company. If your homework is not received within 3 business days, you may forfeit your deposit.

  • 0 out of 5
    Gift Certificate
    $25.00$100.00
    0 out of 5

    Stop in at the bakery in Kalaheo to pick up your Gift Certificate – or we can mail it to you for an additional $1 fee.

    Note: If your gift certificate needs to be mailed to a different address than your billing address — please let us know in the Notes box on the checkout page.

  • 0 out of 5
    Butter Mochi Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Our spin on a Hawaiian favorite. A delicious blend of rice flour, coconut milk and butter for a rich dense pie.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Caramel Apple Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Just like a caramel apple from the fair! Tart, crunchy granny smith apples, topped with a crumb topping and generously drizzled with caramel sauce. Also available Gluten-Free (no crumbs… top crust only.)

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Caramel Apple Pecan Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Just like the fair favorite… granny smith apples piled high and topped with a pecan crumb topping and ooey gooey caramel.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Creamy Carrot Custard Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    A fun twist on traditional pumpkin pie. Organic carrots, locally grown when we can get them, cooked tender and combined with rich custard ingredients. Baked to a creamy perfection. Available all year long!

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    A rich gooey half baked cookie texture. Filled with semi sweet chocolate chips and roasted walnuts. Substitute local macadamia nuts for $1 more.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • Chocolate Coconut Macaroon Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00

    Our most decadent offering. A layer of toasted coconut topped with chocolate ganache and a layer of coconut custard creates this delicious pie. This pie does contain eggs.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Lilikoi Cheesecake (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    A delightful blend of tangy lilikoi with creamy cheesecake make this a top five pie at The Right Slice. Layered on a graham cracker crust, this pie is lighter than its New York Style mainland cousin.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Macadamia Nut Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Another island favorite. We use island macadamia nuts, roasted to a perfect golden brown. Combine this with eggs, sugar and fresh spices for a delicious tropical ending to any meal. Add in chocolate chips or our local Koloa Rum for $3 extra. A Gluten-Free option is also available (but not available with the Rum Mix-In).

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Paradise Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Macadamia Nut Pie with a twist. We add fresh local island pineapple and toasted coconut to our already decadent macadamia nut pie.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    A delicate blend of our traditional vanilla cheesecake and grandma’s pumpkin pie in a graham cracker crust.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Dutch Apple Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    A holiday favorite. Our classic apple pie with a twist. We add a light brown sugar crumb topping and a creamy sauce to your traditional apple pie.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Cranberry Pudding Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    The owner’s favorite! A delightful blend of tart fresh cranberries in a creamy cake-like filling. Add the crunch of toasted walnuts and you have a seasonal delight! Only available if we can get fresh cranberries. Perfect for breakfast or brunch!

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Haupia Purple Sweet Potato Pie (Pickup)
    $35.00
    0 out of 5

    We add a beautiful smooth coconut cream topping to our fresh purple sweet potato pie for an added tropical flair. This pie is a local favorite!

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Rocky Road Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Rich and fudgy… Chocolate, Roasted Almonds and Marshmallows.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Pumpkin Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    A holiday favorite… this is the owner’s grandma’s recipe. You don’t want to miss this one… mixed with just the right autumn spices for a nice holiday flavor.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Pumpkin Pecan Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Can’t choose between two holiday classics? Why not have both? Traditional Pumpkin pie topped with sweet pecan pie!

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Tantric Chocolate Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Rich and fudgy… Chocolate ganache, Roasted Almonds, Candied Ginger and a touch of Cayenne Pepper.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Banana Cream Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    Classic Vanilla Pudding made from scratch and layered with fresh sliced apple bananas. Featuring our locally grown apple bananas, sliced thin. Please note this flavor may occasionally be unavailable based on the ripeness of our current batch of bananas. We are at Mother Nature’s whim. We highly recommend the topping of our homemade whipped cream. Please note that in the tropical Hawaiian heat this pie must be refrigerated ASAP.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.

  • 0 out of 5
    Belgian Chocolate Pie (Pickup)
    $32.00
    0 out of 5

    A chocolate lovers delight! A twist between a dark mousse and a pudding. 55% dark chocolate combined with milk and eggs to create this delicious homemade pastry cream. Fabulous topped with our homemade whipped cream. Add your favorite fixin for $4 extra or 2 fixins for $7. Please note that in the tropical Hawaiian heat this pie must be refrigerated ASAP.

    Available in 3 sizes: Baby (serves 5-6), Medium (serves 8-10) and Large (serves 8-12). See more info in the Description section below.