Due to the continuing worldwide Covid-19 crisis, we have chosen to reduce our staff and open a pick up window in lieu of the Kalaheo retail store, for both their safety and yours. Hours are M-F 12-6, Sat 10-4.

We look forward to reopening the full retail area once Hawaii travel resumes.

At this time we will also not be accepting shipped pie orders. If you would like to place a special order we will be filling those as our ingredient sources allow, and also offering deliveries or pick ups at our Kalaheo location by appointment.

Gift certificates are also available on our website.

Feel free to call us at 808-212-5798.

Thank you for your support over the past 11 years.

This is not goodbye, this is a hui hou! 

~Sandy and Bakers

Place your order online! You can pick up your pies at various locations – or have them shipped to you! Use your PayPal account or your credit card to submit your payment.

Please note that all orders require a minimum of 24 hrs notice.  For orders to be picked up at the market locations, notice may be longer as we often leave several hours before the market to allow for travel and set up times.  We do request that you pick up your pies at our market locations within the first hour of the market if at all possible.

If you are unsure please feel free to call our bakery to confirm your pick up times at (808) 212-5798 or email us at order@rightslice.com


Order a Pie for Pickup

Pick Up a Pie

You will have the option of where to pick up your pies.
Pickup times at each location are as follows:

The Right Slice in Kalaheo
(Full Service Bakery):

Monday-Friday: noon-6pm
Saturday: requires order to be placed over the phone

Kukui’ula Culinary Market:
Wednesday 3:30-4:30

Ship a Pie

Ship a Pie

We have a selection of pies that we can ship
interisland or to the US mainland.

You will have the option of which date you want your pie to ship on.

Please note: we only ship Mondays and Tuesdays
as our pies go out via UPS 2-day air.
Next Day Service is not available from our island.

Please give us 48-hour notice for shipped pies,
to allow for fresh baking and freezing.

Shipping Costs:
Shipping to Hawaii: $48 for 1 pie
plus $8 for each additional pie

Shipping to all other US states: $75 for 1 pie
plus $30 for each additional pie