Order

Bakery Orders

Order online and pick up your pies and other treats at various locations.

Favorite Things

Kauaʻi-made items that can be picked up at our bakery or shipped to you.

Gift Cards

Gift cards are also available and can be redeemed on our website.

Please note:

At this time we will not be accepting shipped pie orders, as our former shipper, UPS, is no longer guaranteeing 2-day shipping from Kauaʻi.

At checkout you will see a Credit Card Fee to enable us to recoup the high costs of accepting online payments.

Feel free to call our bakery at (808) 212-5798 or email us at info@rightslice.com. Thank you for your support over these near 15 years!
~Sandy and Bakers

Pick Up a Pie

Order ahead and pick up your pie at our full-service bakery in Kalaheo seven days a week – or at the Kukuiʻula Culinary Market on Wednesday afternoons!

All orders require a minimum of 24-hour notice.
For orders to be picked up at the farmer’s market location, notice may be longer as we often leave several hours before the market to allow for travel and set up times. We do request that you pick up your pies at our farmer’s market location within the first hour of the beginning of the market. Refunds will not be issued for forgotten pie orders. If you forget, you can pick up your order at the bakery shop the next day.

If you are unsure please feel free to call our bakery to confirm your pick up times at (808) 212-5798 or email us at info@rightslice.com.

Place Your Pie Order

Other Treats

We have added some fun new items to our bakery line-up that are also available for pickup. Stroll down memory lane with Grandma’s recipe for old fashioned whoopie pies. Or try our delicious edible cookie dough in three different flavors. (We also offer other seasonal flavors in store only.)

Order Some Treats

Our Favorite Things

We are thrilled to be partnering with many other Kauai small businesses to bring you fun tastes and sites from Kauaʻi. In addition, we are excited to offer The Right Slice shirts, bags and more!

You can place your order online for these items – and then either pick them up at our Kalaheo bakery or have them shipped to you.

Shop Our Favorites