Our Hawaiian pie flavors are constantly changing. With 50 sweet pie flavors and 31 savory flavors, we have a Hawaiian Pie flavor for every taste! Make sure to check out our Facebook Page for our daily flavors.

Hawaiian Pies

Our large pies are deep dish and baked in your choice of recyclable aluminum pans or glass pie plates. Receive a $10 store credit when you return the glass pan!

We also offer an 8-inch Baby Pie… these serve 4-6 people and can be ordered online for pickup as well.

Deep Dish & Baby Pies

You can enjoy just a slice of our fresh baked pies at our Kalaheo full service bakery, in Lihue at our Pie on the Fly automated location or at any of our community events around the island.

Can’t agree on one flavor?!? Everyone can enjoy their own slice!

Pie by the Slice

Don’t forget those extra special requests. We can do your wedding, birthday or graduation pies with a special order. Looking for a special flavor, it never hurts to ask. We are always experimenting with new ideas. We also offer both Gluten Free and No Sugar Added alternatives. Be sure to note our seasonal flavors as well!

Special Requests

Locations

Where you can find us
in Hawaii

Order Online

Order pies for pickup
– or to be shipped!

Calendar

Our Calendar of Events
in Hawaii

FEATURED PRODUCTS

cupcake

RECENT BLOG POSTS

cupcake

Thanksgiving Pie Ordering is almost closed

We are nearing the Friday deadline for placing your Thanksgiving pie orders.  Friday at 6 pm Hawaii Time is the deadline!  Get those orders in asap!
We, like many small businesses, are very short staffed.  If we get too many orders this week, we may have to close the ordering earlier.
The deep dish pies in our signature glass pans are already sold out for all of next week’s dates.  You can still order our baby pie serving 5-6, or …

Thanksgiving pie orders are now open

Aloha!  Tis the season, or so my customers are telling me!  We have opened Thanksgiving orders for pick up on Wednesday, November 23rd at the bakery in Kalaheo from 11-6 or at the farmer’s market in Poipu from 3:30-5.
You can order online at RightSlice.com/order
or you can call us at the shop and we can help you over the phone.
As of today we plan to accept orders until November 18th at 5 pm.  If we get too many …

Thanksgiving Pie Orders are now Closed

Much Mahalos for your support with the many many Thanksgiving pie orders you placed with us these last 2 weeks!  We probably accepted more than we should have, but we can’t stand to have anyone miss out.
 
But…that being said, orders have now closed.  As of 6 pm Hawaii Time we are no longer taking orders.  If you try to sneak one in on line you will just make more work for Baker Sandy, because she will have to …